![]()
Here's a question worth sitting with: what happens to a local newspaper after you strip out most of the people who actually report the news?
McClatchy, one of the biggest newspaper chains in the country, is about to find out. According to Nieman Journalism Lab, the company has spent years cutting newsrooms down to the bone. Now it's planning to rebuild itself around AI.
I've read that sentence three times and it still sounds backwards to me.
The Towns McClatchy Used to Know
McClatchy owns papers like the Miami Herald, the Kansas City Star, the Sacramento Bee, the Fort Worth Star-Telegram. Papers that used to have dozens of reporters covering city council meetings, high school football, courtrooms, and the guy who ran the hardware store for forty years.
I've driven through a lot of those towns. Small-town newspapers used to be where you found out what actually mattered where you live — not national noise, but the stuff happening three blocks from your house. Who's running for school board. Which road is getting fixed. Whether the water bill is going up.
That kind of reporting takes people. People who show up to meetings, make phone calls, and ask follow-up questions when something doesn't add up. You can't automate curiosity. At least, not yet.
So Why AI?
Money, mostly. McClatchy went through bankruptcy back in 2020 and has been trimming ever since. AI is cheap compared to a newsroom full of salaries, benefits, and expense accounts. It doesn't take vacation. It doesn't unionize. It doesn't call in sick.
I get the appeal from a spreadsheet standpoint. But here's my question: can AI actually replace what a local reporter does, or does it just replace the appearance of what a local reporter does?
Those are two very different things.
AI is genuinely good at summarizing, drafting, organizing data, even writing a decent weather roundup. I use tools like it myself to speed up research when I'm planning a trip or digging into a topic I don't know well. It's a useful assistant. What it can't do is sit across from a grieving mother after a car accident, or notice that a city official's story doesn't match the paperwork, or build the kind of trust that makes a source finally tell you the truth off the record.
That's not a knock on the technology. It's just a fact about what reporting actually is.
Why This Matters to You, Not Just Journalists
Maybe you don't live in a McClatchy town. Maybe you get your news from a phone screen and haven't touched a printed newspaper in years. Fair enough. But think about where that news on your phone actually comes from.
A huge amount of what gets aggregated, shared, and argued about online started as original reporting from a local paper somewhere. Strip out the humans doing that original digging, and you don't get better information. You get less of it, recycled more times, with fewer people checking whether it's actually true.
I've spent years now living a life built on curiosity — asking questions, going places, figuring things out as I go rather than accepting the easy answer. Good journalism runs on that same instinct. Somebody has to ask "wait, why is this happening?" and then actually go find out. An algorithm can write a tidy paragraph about a city budget vote. It can't smell that something's off in the room.
What I'll Be Watching
I'm curious, not panicked. Experiments like this sometimes fail spectacularly and sometimes teach an industry something useful about what actually matters to readers. Maybe McClatchy finds a hybrid that works — AI handling the repetitive stuff, freeing up the few remaining humans to do real digging. That would be worth watching.
Or maybe this is what it looks like when a company runs out of other ideas.
Either way, it's a reminder that the stuff we take for granted — a local paper, a nosy reporter, a town that gets covered honestly — doesn't survive on autopilot. Somebody has to keep showing up and asking questions.
Worth asking yourself: who's still showing up to ask questions in your town? And if the answer is "nobody," what does that actually cost you?
Source: Nieman Journalism Lab
Earlier in this series: Why 131 Organizations Just Told Congress "Deception Shouldn't Be a Business Model"