Albany Shouldn’t Police Newsrooms’ AI Use


Albany Shouldn’t Police Newsrooms’ AI Use

 

Who gets to decide how a newsroom writes its stories? That's the question sitting underneath a push in Albany to regulate AI use in New York journalism — and it's worth asking out loud before anyone hands that power to a state legislature.

I've spent years writing on the road, filing stories from wherever I happen to be — a campsite in Baja, a coffee shop in Lisbon, a public library in some town I can't always remember the name of. I use tools. Research tools, editing tools, and yes, AI tools when they help me think faster or check a fact. The tool doesn't write my story. I do. But I've learned enough about how these systems work to know the conversation around them is messier than most lawmakers want to admit.

That's exactly the problem with letting a state capitol set the rules for how newsrooms operate.

Who gets to decide?

Journalism in this country has survived because nobody in government gets to tell a newsroom how to report, write, or edit a story. That's not a technicality — it's the whole point. The moment a legislature starts writing rules about which tools reporters can use and how they must disclose them, you've opened a door that's awfully hard to close again.

Think about it this way. If Albany can mandate how a paper uses AI today, what stops it from deciding tomorrow that certain sourcing methods need pre-approval, or that certain topics require a government-sanctioned process? Once you accept the premise that lawmakers should police editorial tools, you've accepted that editorial independence is negotiable. It isn't.

And here's the thing I keep coming back to: AI in newsrooms isn't one single practice. Some outlets use it to transcribe interviews. Some use it to sort data in investigative pieces. Some, unfortunately, use it to generate entire articles with a human barely glancing at the result. Those are wildly different situations, and lumping them into one law written by people who may not fully understand the technology is a recipe for bad policy.

What good journalism actually needs

I'm not arguing newsrooms get a free pass. Readers deserve to know when a story was shaped heavily by AI versus reported the old-fashioned way — knocking on doors, making calls, sitting across from a source and asking a follow-up question because something didn't add up. That's trust, and trust is earned by the newsroom, not legislated by the state.

The better path is transparency built from inside journalism itself — editors' standards, newsroom policies, industry associations setting disclosure norms. That's messier than a single law. It's also more adaptable, which matters a lot when the technology keeps changing every few months. A law passed this year could be outdated by the time it's enforced.

I've made enough mistakes chasing new tools and new ways of doing things to know that rigid rules written too early usually miss the real problem. What happens if AI gets better at fact-checking than a tired reporter on deadline? What happens if it gets worse, and some outlet leans on it anyway to cut costs? Those are editorial and ethical questions. They're not legislative ones.

Why this matters to you

If you read the news — and you probably do, or you wouldn't be here — this fight isn't abstract. It's about whether the stories you read are shaped by editors answering to readers, or by a regulatory framework answering to politicians. Independence is the whole value proposition of a free press. Hand that over, even with good intentions, and you've changed what journalism is.

I've built a life around the idea that freedom to choose how you work matters more than permission from an authority who isn't in the room. Newsrooms deserve that same freedom — paired with real accountability to the people who actually read their work.

Albany should stay out of the newsroom. Readers, editors, and the industry itself can figure out the AI question faster, and better, than any legislature ever could.

Source: New York Daily News

Before this, we covered: When Google Isn't the Only One Reading Your Website Anymore