James Blake didn't mince words. Last summer, the British producer posted on Instagram that there's "not a single part of the system that isn't faked" in music anymore. Album reviews, comment sections, streaming numbers—all of it, he says, gets manipulated for profit.
Is he right? I started poking around, and honestly, the deeper I went, the weirder it got.
I've spent years traveling full-time, which means I spend a lot of time in airports and hotel rooms with headphones on, discovering new music from places I've never been. So when I hear that the whole industry might be built on smoke and mirrors, I want to know: what's actually real anymore?
Turns out, 2026 has been a wild year for that question.
The Band That Got Called a "Psyop"
In March, two guys from a marketing agency called Chaotic Good Projects admitted on a podcast at SXSW that part of their job is creating fake fan accounts to hype up artists online. Musician Eliza McLamb wrote about it, WIRED picked it up, and suddenly an article existed with the headline "The Fanfare Around the Band Geese Is a Psyop."
Geese frontman Cameron Winter said the band had no idea. "We were just like, 'Oh my God, the whole f***ing thing is fake,'" he told Rolling Stone. Turns out their label hired Chaotic Good to push clips onto algorithms—not to fake fans. But the damage was done. Now anyone who blows up overnight gets side-eyed.
Tickets, Bots, and Clones
Ticketmaster canceled thousands of Harry Styles tickets this spring after discovering scalpers had used fake identities to dodge purchase limits. Jack Antonoff's response on X? "you caught you?" Fair point.
Then there's the Shakira body-double theory during the World Cup opening ceremony in Mexico City, and the Usher "clone" accusations after his MetLife Stadium show in August—fans swore his jawline looked different. Usher's response on Instagram: "AI ain't that advanced." He's probably right, but the fact that people believe it could be says something about where we are.
When Old Rockers Get De-Aged
Here's the one that actually made me laugh. The Rolling Stones released a video this summer for "In the Stars," and Mick Jagger, Keith Richards and Ronnie Wood all appear as younger versions of themselves—created by Deep Voodoo, an AI studio founded by the South Park guys. Jagger sang about "what a drag it is getting old" back in 1966. Sixty years later, he can just undo it on screen. I'm almost 70 myself, and I'll admit, that's one trick I wouldn't mind trying—though I'd rather earn my adventures the old-fashioned way, by actually going out and having them.
Bots Making Music for Other Bots
Deezer reported that in June, AI-generated songs made up more than half of its daily uploads. But those songs got less than 3% of total streams—and most of those were fake, bot-driven plays. Spotify deleted half a million streams from Malcolm Todd's song "Earrings" after discovering manipulation tied to bets on a prediction market called Kalshi.
So now Spotify is labeling AI personas that pose as real artists, separate from AI used in production. It's a start. But it tells you something: the platforms themselves are admitting they can't fully police what's real.
Even the Critics Are Paid
Short-form video reviewers have become the new tastemakers, the modern version of radio DJs. NPR talked to five of them who admitted they take undisclosed payments from labels. One honest holdout, Derrick Gee, put it bluntly: "Average Joe from Denver starts with a passion for music and in a year is pushing slop because someone paid him to."
So What's Actually Real?
Gracie Abrams debuted at No. 1 with Daughter From Hell despite nonstop "nepo baby" accusations. Geese is selling out arenas. And there's a boy band called Boy Throb that started as a TikTok joke about getting a member a visa—and ended up signing with Kesha. Sometimes the absurd thing is the genuine thing.
That's the part I keep coming back to. The fakes get the headlines, but people are still packing stadiums, still screaming lyrics back at strangers. Maybe the real story isn't that everything's fake—it's that we have to work harder to find what isn't. And honestly? That's always been true of anything worth chasing.
Source: NPR
If you missed it: Visa Just Redesigned Itself For a World Where AI Might Do Your Shopping
